民主的方向—评林垚《灯塔主义与中国自由派知识分子的“川化”》

节选:在我看来,林文真正要揭示的并不是中国自由派知识分子是不是应该寻找和依赖指明灯的问题,也不是美国有没有资格当指明灯的问题,而是中国自由派知识分子对民主的认知问题以及造成这种认知的价值基础问题。比如说,在分析美国的一系列社会问题时,美国自由派知识分子认为,这些问题的根源在于美国社会结构的不平等以及分配不公,因此他们主张以扩大社会公平为政治取向、向弱势群体进行倾斜的分配政策。 ======================   终于有时间细读林垚发表在Journal of Contemporary China的Beaconism and the Trumpian Metamorphosis of Chinese Liberal Intellectuals一文 (以下简称林文)。该文在今年年初发表之后,广受关注。以下是我对该文的几点看法。 首先是我对林文主要观点的理解。 从林文的标题来看,它的主要解释对象是中国自由派知识分子中的存在的所谓“川粉现象”或“川普情节”。但是在具体讨论时,作者对非自由派中国知识分子的川普情节也有提及(for the section…

Continue Reading →

2021: The Birth of Xi Jinping Thought (习近平思想)?

I’m starting to suspect that the rectification campaign that will sweep through China’s political-legal bureaucracy in 2021 might be a…

Continue Reading →

Ducks, rabbits, and the case of Meng Wanzhou

The U.S. government and Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou are reportedly negotiating a deal that would permit her to leave Canada…

Continue Reading →

Appeal of Strategic Ambiguity on Party Centre – Reading the Party Directive on the Operation of the Central Committee (Part I)

[social_warfare] It is easy to dismiss the value of any written rules laid down by the Party because the latter…

Continue Reading →

New political-legal rectification campaign 2020-2021

A new nation-wide rectification campaign targeting political-legal institutions, incl. courts, procuratorates, police, prisons, administrative body for lawyers… It’ll begin in…

Continue Reading →

Beaconism and the Trumpian Metamorphosis of Chinese Liberal Intellectuals

“Civilizational beaconism, sharing with its nationalistic counterpart—civilizational vindicativism—the heritages of scientific racism and social Darwinism imported in late-Qing, renders the…

Continue Reading →

Discussion: how come China’s courts acquitted more people during the Cultural Revolution than they do now?

Prof. Clarke’s recent post show that the acquittal rates in 1966-1969 were nearly 25 times higher than that of 2013-2016.…

Continue Reading →

Rebranding of weiwen and rebirth of Zhou Yongkang’s stability maintenance committee 解析平安中国建设协调小组和中央综治委

The latest Ping’an China Small-Group re-erects the stability maintenance steering machine that had grown significantly under Zhou Yongkang but was…

Continue Reading →

Why are heroes so important in narrative construction of public crises?

Yesterday, a reporter asked me: Why do state media and officials praise individuals for their heroic actions in a public…

Continue Reading →

A quick guide to the new Commission on Comprehensive Governance according to Law (CCGAL)

What is the Central Party CCGAL? It is a newly established decision-making body at the highest rank that is mandated…

Continue Reading →